Why Are Payday Loans Called Short-term Loans: Key Insights for Lenders

Brian Allen
Nov 22, 2024
8 mins read
Why Are Payday Loans Called Short-term Loans: Key Insights for Lenders

I’ve been asked these same questions about payday loans so many times that I decided it was time to address them all in one go:

  • Why are payday loans classified as short-term loans?
  • What sets payday loans apart from other types of short-term loans?
  • Are payday loans regulated in the same way as other short-term loans?

If you’re a lender, you’ve probably encountered these questions too. Payday loans occupy a distinct position in short-term financing. Understanding why they are classified as such and how they differ from other loan types can greatly impact how you approach this market.

In this blog, I’ll not only answer these burning questions but also discuss how payday loans compare to other short-term lending options, along with the regulations that come with them. 

Whether you’re offering payday loans already or just exploring the idea, this will give you the insights you need to sort through the complexities of payday lending effectively and responsibly.

Payday loans are classified as short-term loans due to its several defining features:

Immediate Repayment Timeline

Repayment is usually due within two weeks to a month, offering a quick resolution but requiring prompt collection. This makes it very different from loans with extended repayment periods.

Fast Disbursement

Payday loans are appealing for their quick access to cash, often available within hours of approval, which attracts borrowers who might not qualify for traditional credit.

High Fees and Interest Rates

Because of their fast turnaround and minimal requirements, payday loans come with high fees, resulting in APRs (Annual Percentage Rates) that can be much higher than those of other loan types.

For a lender, these features can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, they meet urgent borrower needs; on the other, they can lead to high default rates. Knowing these characteristics can help you align your offerings with your borrower’s needs while keeping the risks in check.

Payday loans differ from other short-term lending options in various aspects. Below, I’ve outlined key differences between payday loans and other popular short-term loan types, such as personal loans, installment loans, credit card cash advances, and lines of credit. 

This comparison clearly highlights payday loans’ distinctive characteristics along with their similarities, which will help you make informed decisions about your loan offerings.

Loan Comparison Table
Payday Loans
Other Short-Term Loans
Eligibility
Minimal requirements, no credit check
  • Personal Loans: Credit check required, and other stricter requirements
  • Installment Loans: Varies, usually requires fair-to-good credit
  • Credit Card Cash Advances: Requires an active credit card account
  • Lines of Credit: Requires credit check and often a fair-to-good credit
Approval Speed
Very fast, often within a day
  • Personal Loans: Moderate, usually takes a few days
  • Installment Loans: Moderate, can be processed quickly
  • Credit Card Cash Advances: Instant if the card is active
  • Lines of Credit: Moderate to fast, depending on the lender
Collateral Requirement
Not Needed
  • Personal Loans: Typically requires no collateral, but some lenders may ask for it
  • Installment Loans: No, unsecured; can be secured in some cases
  • Credit Card Cash Advances: No, but tied to existing credit card
  • Lines of Credit: No for most; some secured credit lines available
Interest Rates & Fees
High APR (often reaching 400%)
  • Personal Loans: Moderate to high APR, often lower than payday
  • Installment Loans: Moderate APR, varies based on risk
  • Credit Card Cash Advances: High APR, often between 20%-30%
  • Lines of Credit: Variable APR, generally lower than payday rates
Repayment Terms
Lump-sum by next payday
  • Personal Loans: Monthly installments, typically 1-5 years
  • Installment Loans: Monthly installments, with a set schedule
  • Credit Card Cash Advances: Paid through monthly card balance payments
  • Lines of Credit: Revolving balance, with flexible repayment terms
Target Borrower
Individuals needing fast cash, often with low credit
  • Personal Loans: General borrowers with fair to good credit
  • Installment Loans: Those seeking short-term financing
  • Credit Card Cash Advances: Existing cardholders needing quick cash
  • Lines of Credit: Borrowers needing flexible and ongoing access to cash
Benefits for Lenders
High returns due to high fees and APRs
  • Personal Loans: Reliable borrower base and lower default risk
  • Installment Loans: Steady and predictable payments
  • Credit Card Cash Advances: Immediate access to funds and profitable fees
  • Lines of Credit: Flexible capital usage and steady income from interest
Risks for Lenders
High default rate and heavy regulation
  • Personal Loans: Lower returns and requires credit screening
  • Installment Loans: Moderate risk of default with flexible terms
  • Credit Card Cash Advances: Risk of maxed credit limits and borrower default
  • Lines of Credit: Fluctuating balances and risk if borrower overdraws

Yes, payday loans are regulated as short-term loans in many states to protect both borrowers and lenders. These regulations are designed to ensure responsible lending practices, promote transparency, and prevent borrowers from falling into deep debt cycles. 

Some of the most common ones are:

Limits on Rates and Fees

Many states set interest rate caps and fee limits for payday loans to prevent costs from spiraling out of control. 

So, make sure to keep a track of these state-specific regulations to ensure that your payday loan products remain compliant.

Loan Amounts and Terms

Most states place restrictions on how much borrowers can take out and how quickly they need to pay it back. 

These terms encourage quick repayment and discourage prolonged debt, serving as a useful guide for structuring responsible loan offerings.

Borrower Protections 

Regulations are also in place to safeguard borrowers from falling into a cycle of debt.

By understanding and complying with such policies, you can build trust with your borrowers and offer a more responsible lending service.

Staying up-to-date with these regulations is essential to ensure that your payday loan offerings remain fair and safeguard your business from potential legal risks.

At Bryt Software, we believe that responsible lending is the foundation of a successful, sustainable business. In my view, offering payday loans or similar products requires careful consideration of borrower welfare and proactive risk management.

So, here are some practices I recommend:

Assess Borrower Affordability

To assess a borrower’s affordability, it’s essential to consider factors beyond just credit scores. Make sure to look into your borrower’s income stability, debt-to-income ratio (DTI), employment history, monthly expenses, emergency savings, and recent bank statements.  

These elements will provide you with a clearer picture of their ability to manage debt and repay the loan responsibly.

Be Transparent About the Terms

I’ve found that clear, upfront communication about repayment schedules, fees, and potential penalties goes a long way in maintaining borrower trust.

Also, make sure to draft proper documents outlining these terms and conditions to avoid any confusion or misunderstandings down the line.

Provide Flexible Repayment Options

When possible, offer options like extended payment plans or installment options. In addition to this, you can also consider offering grace periods, loan extensions, payment rescheduling or debt consolidation options. However, make sure that you offer these flexibilities based on their payment history.

Providing the borrower with such options can help you build trust, reduce defaults, and encourage long-term loyalty, benefiting both you and your borrowers.

Educate Your Borrowers

Educating borrowers about payday loan terms and costs helps prevent misunderstandings. For instance, explain how a $100 loan with a $20 fee could grow to $120, or how late fees and rollovers can escalate debt.

Clear communication empowers borrowers to make informed decisions and avoid financial strain.

Consider Limiting Loan Frequency

Setting a cap on payday loans can prevent borrowers from falling into debt traps. For example, a rule that limits borrowers to no more than three payday loans within 90 days can stop repeated borrowing that spirals into escalating debt.

Such caps promote responsible lending with its sustainable repayment terms, reducing the risk of defaults and improving borrower outcomes over time.

At Bryt Software, we aim to support lenders in adopting these best practices by offering comprehensive loan management software. 

If you’re looking to offer more responsible lending products or need help navigating the complexities of loan management, Bryt Software is here to help.

Brian Allen is the Chief Information Officer (CIO) at Bryt Software

Brian Allen

About Brian Allen
Brian Allen is the Chief Information Officer (CIO) at Bryt Software, where he leads developing next-gen loan management and servicing software solutions. With over 18+ years experience in the industry, Brian is an expert known for his technical excellence. Before joining Bryt Software, Brian co-owned RTEffects, a renowned provider of...

​© 2024 Bryt Software LCC. All Rights Reserved.